Getting a stalled HR system project back on track: reset or switch?
By Zené Olivier / Alexandra Wagener · Zanani People Solutions, Cape Town
6 min read

Starting over feels clean. It is rarely the cheapest or fastest way back.
You can usually recover a stalled HR system project without starting again. Pause, find out what is really wrong, reset who decides, shrink the next goal, and rebuild trust with employees. Switch systems only when the system truly cannot do what you need and the vendor cannot fix it. Then plan the switch with care, because contracts, data and payroll timing all carry risk.
In our view, most stalled projects have a people, process or decision problem, not a software problem. Those can be fixed without throwing away the work already done.
First, find out what is really wrong
Ask three questions:
- Can the system do what we need, if it is set up properly?
- Do we know who decides, and are they available?
- Do employees and managers know what is coming, and why?
If the answer to the first question is yes, you can probably recover. If it is no, read the section on switching below.
A five-step reset
1. Pause and listen
Stop adding new scope for a short time. Talk to HR, payroll, IT, the vendor, line managers, and a few employees. Ask what is working, what is not and what worries them.
Listen before you judge. Pushback often comes from workload, past experience, or missing information.
2. Get the facts on one page
Write a summary: scope, open decisions, data quality, process gaps, training and communication. Keep it factual. Share it with the sponsor and the vendor.
3. Reset who decides
- Name one executive sponsor who can unblock decisions.
- Name one HR owner for the people side.
- Agree who recommends, who gives input, and who makes the final call.
Put it in writing. Then stick to it.
It can help to get everyone in one room. In a South African Workday rollout, the implementation partner said it was "incredible how you can move forward if you have everyone in a room together" (CHRO South Africa, Mastering Workday implementation).
4. Shrink the next goal
Do not try to fix everything at once. Pick a smaller first release people will notice. For example, get payslips and leave working well for one group first.
The same Workday session advised starting simply, because it is easier to add complexity later. A visible early win rebuilds trust and gives you real feedback.
5. Rebuild trust with employees
When a project stalls, employees notice. Rumours fill the silence.
Tell people what went wrong, in plain words. Say what changes now, and when - in fact advertise it!. Give them a way to ask questions. Then show what you did with their input.
McKinsey's research on AI adoption warns that when trust breaks down, people slide back. Its advice: treat lost trust as a signal to go back a step, not to push harder (McKinsey, How to close the agentic adoption gap).
"Systems don't change organisations. People do." Zanani People Solutions
When switching is the right call
Switching makes sense when:
- The system cannot handle your South African payroll, reporting or structure, and the vendor cannot fix it.
- The vendor cannot support you, after clear and fair chances to do so.
- The system will not fit where your organisation is heading. CHRO South Africa suggests asking if a system will still fit you in three years (CHRO South Africa, Your HRMS should adapt to your business).
It usually does not make sense when the real problem is ownership, process or communication. Those problems will follow you to the next system.
How to change vendors mid-contract
If you do switch, plan it like a new project.
- Read the contract. Check notice periods, exit terms and what you still owe. Get legal advice.
- Secure your data. Agree how and when you get all your data out, in a usable format, including history.
- Plan for overlap. You may pay for both systems for a while. Budget for it.
- Time payroll carefully. The South African tax year starts on 1 March. Switching mid-year means moving year-to-date figures for every employee.
- Check POPIA. Make sure the old provider deletes or returns data as agreed.
- Learn the lessons. Fix ownership and process first, so the new project does not stall in the same place.
- Talk to employees. Explain why you are switching, and what it means for them.
An example
Picture a healthcare group whose HR system project had stalled for four months. Leaders wanted to switch.
A frank look showed the system could do what they needed. The real problem was that nobody owned the design approvals, so the build kept changing and shifting aimlessly. They named an owner, went live with leave for one region first and kept the system.
Try this on Monday
List every open decision on your project. Next to each, write who should make it and by when. If you cannot name a person, that is your first problem to fix, before any talk of switching.
How Zanani helps
Zanani is an HR technology adoption partner and HR advisory. We help stalled projects find their way back, or switch with care when that is the right call. Here is what that looks like for you:
- A clear answer. You know if this is a reset or a switch, and why.
- Decisions that get made. Ownership is clear, and the project moves again.
- An early win. A smaller first release that people notice.
- Trust rebuilt. Employees and managers hear what is happening, in plain words.
We work directly with organisations, and we also work with HR technology providers. Every organisation is different, so let's talk about how we do it.
FAQ
Can you recover an HR system project without starting again?
Usually, yes. If the system can do what you need, resetting ownership, scope and communication is often enough.
When should we change HR system vendors mid-contract?
Only when the system truly cannot meet your needs and the vendor cannot fix it, after fair chances. Ownership or process problems will follow you to a new system.
How do we change vendors mid-contract?
Check exit terms, secure your data, budget for overlap, time payroll carefully, check POPIA duties and fix ownership first.
Who should lead the reset?
The executive sponsor, with the HR owner. An outside partner can help keep the view balanced.
How do we know the reset is working?
Decisions get made in the meeting, open issues go down each week and staff questions shift from "why?" to "how?".
Project stalled? Email info@zanani.co.za or see what we do. We would love to talk.
FAQ: How do we support your digital journey?
