Home/Insights/Choosing an HR system

System Selection

Choosing an HR system: what to ask before you sign

By Zené Olivier / Alexandra Wagener · Zanani People Solutions, Cape Town

7 min read

The demo is the easy part. The questions you ask before you sign decide how the next few years feel.

To choose an HR system, start with your own problems and processes, not a feature list. Then ask every vendor the same hard questions: will it fit how we work, will it handle South African payroll and reporting, who will do the work, how is our people data protected, and what happens after go-live. Plan the rollout just as carefully as you plan the system requirements and scope. Make sure you have a clear project plan before you sign the system contract.

In our view, most selection regrets are not about the software. They come from questions nobody asked in time.

Start with your problems, not the brochure

Before you speak to any vendor, write down what is not working today. Use plain words.

  • Leave requests take too long to approve.
  • Payroll checks take days every month.
  • Managers cannot see their team's leave or overtime.
  • Reports for the board are built by hand in spreadsheets.

Then build a small buying team. Include HR, payroll, finance, IT and one or two line managers. TechTarget's buying guide suggests the same mix, and asks the team to rank what they need by importance (TechTarget, How to choose an HR software system).

Sort every need into two lists: must have, and nice to have. Your must-have list is your test.

Questions to ask every vendor before you sign

Ask every vendor the same questions, in writing. Compare the answers side by side.

1. Will it fit how we work?

CHRO South Africa recently published a useful list of questions to ask any HR system provider. The first one is the most important: can the system adapt to our structure and processes, rather than forcing us to adapt to it? (CHRO South Africa, Your HRMS should adapt to your business)

The same list asks if the system connects with the finance and other systems you already use, and if it will still fit your organisation in three years. And what are the system's integration capabilities?

Ask for a demo built on your own real tasks, not the vendor's sample company. TechTarget recommends demos using real use cases from your organisation.

2. Will it handle South African rules?

A system that works well overseas may need extra work here. Ask each vendor to show, not just tell:

  • Payroll and tax. PAYE, UIF and SDL, the monthly EMP201, and the EMP501 reconciliation with IRP5 certificates.
  • Employment Equity. The fields you need for your EE reports, if you are a designated employer.
  • Skills. Training records for your Workplace Skills Plan and Annual Training Report to your SETA.
  • Leave. Leave rules under the Basic Conditions of Employment Act.

Be careful with big claims. CHRO South Africa notes that an HR system does not, by itself, deliver B-BBEE compliance. Good data supports it. It does not replace specialist advice.

3. Who will actually do the work?

Ask who will be on the implementation team, and what they have done before in South Africa. Ask to speak to a client of a similar size.

Then ask what they expect from your side. One lesson from a South African Workday rollout: for the people involved, "you get a day job plus a project" (CHRO South Africa, Mastering Workday implementation). Know that before you sign.

4. How is our people data protected?

Your employee records are personal information under POPIA. Ask where the data is stored, who can see it and what your agreement with the provider covers. CHRO South Africa lists consent, security safeguards, breach reporting and data retention as points to check.

5. What happens after go-live?

  • What support do we get, and how fast?
  • Who trains new employees next year?
  • What do changes cost after go-live?
  • If we leave, how do we get all our data out?

6. What will it really cost?

Ask for a price in rand, over at least three years. Include setup, data migration, integrations, training and changes. If the price is in dollars or euros, show the exchange-rate risk.

"Systems don't change organisations. People do." — Zanani People Solutions

Should your adviser also be your implementer?

Both models can work. The right approach depends on the organisation's internal HR structure, systems expertise and available capacity.

Separating the advisory and implementation roles can provide greater independence during system selection, reduce potential bias, strengthen accountability and ensure that business requirements remain central to decisions. It can also help build internal capability and maintain HR ownership throughout the process.

Where sufficient internal expertise exists, a single partner may be equally effective.

Ultimately, what matters is having the right balance of expertise, independent challenge and governance to make informed decisions.

Why planning starts before you buy

The contract sets the scope, the timeline, the team and the budget for changes. If training, communication and data clean-up are not in the plan, they quietly become your problem later.

Start early:

  • Check that your own team has time for the project.
  • Start cleaning your employee data now.
  • Determine your project team, with clearly defined roles of responsibility, accountability, and key decision makers.
  • Plan the communication and change plan, and at which touchpoints employees are involved.

The Workday lessons above make the same point. Make sure you have the right skills and capacity inside the team before any implementation, and prepare the team before the project starts. This requires people who could be seconded or deputised to the project team to hand their day-to-day tasks to others in the team for a while.

An example

Picture a retail group with twenty stores. HR chose a system from a service provider after a very polished demo. However, the demo used the service provider's sample data. After signing the contract, the team found that their store shift patterns needed extra set-up. Nobody had asked to see the real store schedule in the demo. The system had the features, but the question came too late. Extra cost followed.

Try this on Monday

Write your top five "this must work" tasks on one page. For example: "A store manager approves leave on a phone." Send the same page to every vendor. Ask each one to demo exactly those five tasks.

How Zanani helps

Zanani is an HR technology adoption partner and HR advisory. We help you choose with your eyes open, so the system fits, the process works and people use it. Here is what that looks like for you:

  • Clear needs. You know what you need before you speak to vendors.
  • A fair comparison. Shortlisted systems are tested against your real tasks.
  • A case leaders can sign. The cost and the people side are both in the plan.
  • A rollout that can land. People, process and data are ready for Go Live and beyond.

We work directly with organisations, and we also work with HR technology providers. Every organisation is different, so let's talk about how we do it.

FAQ

What questions should we ask an HR system vendor before we sign?

Ask if it fits how you work, if it handles South African payroll and reporting, who will do the work, how your data is protected under POPIA, what happens after go-live and what it really costs over three years.

How do you choose an HR software system?

Start with your problems, not features. Build a small buying team, rank your needs and ask every vendor to demo your real tasks.

Looking back, what do HR teams wish they had asked?

Who exactly is on the implementation team, what is expected from their own employees, and what changes cost after go-live.

Should our HR system adviser also be our implementer?

Both models can work, depending on internal HR and systems capability, although separating the roles can offer greater independence, reduce bias and strengthen accountability throughout selection and implementation.

Why should implementation planning start before we buy?

The contract sets scope, timeline and budget. If training, communication and data clean-up are not planned before you sign, they become your problem later.

Choosing a new HR system? Email info@zanani.co.za or see what we do. We would love to talk.

FAQ: How do we support your digital journey?