Home/Insights/Is your project in trouble?
Is your HR system project in trouble? The warning signs, and why projects fail
By Zené Olivier / Alexandra Wagener · Zanani People Solutions, Cape Town
6 min read

One warning sign is normal. Three or more together is a reason to stop and take stock, before go-live, not after.
Your HR system project is likely in trouble if decisions keep slipping, HR is not leading, the data is not trusted and employees are not being properly consulted and prepared. Most HR system projects fail on the people side, not the software side: unclear ownership, poor leadership support, rushed training, and change that nobody explains. The good news is that drift is cheaper to fix early.
In our view, a struggling project rarely has one big problem. It has several small ones that nobody named in time.
Why HR system projects fail
The research points to people more than technology. AIHR reports that 88% of transformations fall short of their ambitions. Employee resistance affects 39% of the workforce, and about a third of failed transformations are directly linked to a lack of executive and management support (AIHR, 7 HR digital transformation challenges).
AIHR also points to Prosci's benchmarking: initiatives with excellent change management are seven times more likely to meet their objectives than those with poor change management.
The usual causes:
- Nobody clearly owns decisions.
- Leaders sign off the budget, then step away.
- The process is copied, not improved.
- Data is not ready.
- Employees are told too late, or not at all.
- Training happens once, at the end, and may have been ineffective in its delivery.
- The project stops at go-live, so adoption is nobody's job after the Go Live date has passed.
Seven warning signs
1. Decisions keep getting parked
The same questions come up in every meeting. Nobody is sure who has the final say. The project slows, and the vendor fills the gap.
2. HR is not leading its own project
IT or the vendor runs the show. HR attends but does not decide, participate, or take responsibility. An HR system shapes every employee's experience, so HR needs a clear seat at the table.
3. The go-live date moved, and nobody can say why
Dates move on most projects. The warning sign is a vague reason, or a new date with no plan behind it.
4. The data is not ready
Employee records live in spreadsheets, old systems, and email. ID numbers, tax numbers and missing fields.If you do not trust the data going in, you will not trust the reports coming out.
5. Old processes are being rebuilt in the new system
Nobody has mapped how current processes should work in future. A new system on an unclear process just makes the confusion faster. The new system must be built with improved and optimised process flows top of mind.
6. Employees know little, and training is in the last week
Employees and managers have heard rumours, not plans. Training is one session just before go-live, with nothing for shift workers or people without email.
7. Nobody can say what success looks like
Ask five people what "done" means. If you get five answers, there is no shared target. Go-live is a date. It is not the same as success.
"Systems don't change organisations. People do." Zanani People Solutions
What to do if you see three or more
- Pause and take stock. Look at scope, decisions, data, process, people and communication. Take stock of what is working successfully too.
- Name one decision maker. Agree who decides, who gives input and who signs off. Put it in writing and share it with the vendor.
- Put HR back in the lead. HR owns the people side: process, communication, training and adoption. The vendor owns the technology.
- Fix the data now. Start clean-up now, not at cut-over. Remember that moving employee data brings POPIA duties.
- Start talking to employees. Say what is changing, when and why. Use the channels people actually use.
- Agree what "working" means. Pick a few simple measures for after go-live.
- Bring leaders back in. Ask the sponsor to show up, ask questions and clear blockers.
If the project has already stalled, our article on getting a stalled project back on track goes further.
An example
Picture an HR director at a financial services firm, six months into a rollout. The weekly meeting had become a status update. The same five decisions were "pending" every week.
She listed the open decisions, named one owner for each and asked the sponsor to join for a month. Three weeks later, four were made. The project did not need a new system. It needed people who could decide and take responsibility for delivery on that decision.
Try this on Monday
Score your project against the seven signs. Ask three people (HR, payroll and a line manager) to tick the signs they see. Compare answers. Any sign ticked by two or more people goes on next week's agenda.
How Zanani helps
Zanani is an HR technology adoption partner and HR advisory. We come in mid-project when a project needs a reset, clearer ownership or adoption support. Here is what that looks like for you:
- An honest view. You see what is working and what is not, in plain words.
- Clear ownership. Decisions have owners, and they get made.
- Getting people back on board. Employees and managers know what is coming and why.
- A path to go-live. A realistic plan that people believe in.
We work directly with organisations, and we also work with HR technology providers. Every organisation is different, so let's talk about how we do it.
FAQ
Why do HR system implementations fail?
Mostly on the people side: unclear ownership, poor leadership support, processes copied instead of improved, data that is not ready and training that comes too late or that is inefficiently delivered.
How do I know if my HR system implementation is failing?
Watch for parked decisions, moving dates with no plan, untrusted data, employees who know little, and no shared idea of success. Three or more together is a reason to act.
Should we stop the project?
Not always. Often a pause, clear decision owners and a fresh plan are enough. Stopping completely is a much bigger decision.
Who should own an HR system project?
HR should own the people and process side. IT and the vendor own the technology. One named person should make final decisions.
Can we still fix it if we are half-way?
Yes. Drift is cheaper to fix early, so act as soon as you see the signs.
Seeing the warning signs? Email info@zanani.co.za or see what we do. We would love to talk.
FAQ: How do we support your digital journey?
